11/22/63: Stephen King’s Love Letter to the Past
What happens when an alternate-history novel becomes a story about love, memory, and letting go?
Would you change history if you could?
It’s a question debated for years, decades, and maybe even centuries. It’s the bread and butter of time-travel fiction. What if you could go back in time and kill Hitler as a baby? Or stop the terrorists on 9/11? Or stop the American Civil War? Or, as in Stephen King’s 2011 novel, 11/22/63, prevent the assassination of President John Kennedy sixty-three years ago today.
I think many historians consider Kennedy’s death a watershed moment, a dividing line from what was and what came after. Sometimes, thinking like this boils the world down to a single variable when, in fact, there are nearly infinite variables that make up our collective history.
I didn’t live through that day in Dallas in November 1963, a mere week before Thanksgiving. Stephen King did. And in 2011, he published a book that examined one way history might have been changed, and the cost it would inflict.
A Doorway to 1958
In 2011, Jake Epping is a high school English teacher in Maine who also teaches the remedial GED class. One day, he’s approached by Al, the owner of a local diner, and Jake can’t quite accept what his eyes are seeing. Al, seemingly overnight, not only has aged, but he’s now got cancer. In the fashion of nearly every other type of story like this, Al is cryptic as to why and how he looks so much older but convinces Jake to step inside the diner’s pantry. Reluctantly, Jake does, and finds himself in September 1958.
Jake spends some time in 1958, not quite realizing how it’s all happening before returning to 2011. He discovers that only two minutes have passed. That’s the rule for this story: the portal always leads to 9 September 1958 and the return is always two minutes later in 2011 time, no matter how long you were back in time.
That’s when Al tells him the truth: people who go through the portal can change the past. As an experiment, Jake returns to 1958 intending to stop the slaughter of a family, the only survivor in 2011 being the learning disabled janitor. Jake succeeds, but then learns the consequence of his actions. (I’ll cover the SF-nature of one time travel idea in the spoiler section down below.)
Through other machinations, Jake resolves to take up the mission Al gave him: travel back to 1958, live in that world for five years, and prevent the assassination of John Kennedy. To do this, however, he will need to do two things: find and investigate Lee Harvey Oswald and establish himself in the society of the late 1950s and early 1960s.
A Love Letter to the Past
And this is where King’s novel shines. But only if you are ready for it. Because what King ultimately does is write a non-supernatural novel. And, yes, a love story.
I could imagine when this novel was published in 2011, readers might have expected a full alternate history as told by King. What they get is a peek into life in those five years. King himself would have been eleven in 1958, sixteen when Kennedy was killed. So in some ways, this is a love letter to his formative years. A time when everything was cheaper, more well made, and life just seemed simpler. I know everyone thinks that, especially when all the adulting we have to do starts inundating us.
As much as we might want to return to the years of our youth, could we really live in that era again? Would you want to?
Is Stephen King Better Without the Horror?
As I became engrossed with the story of Jake—he assumes the name George Amberson—as he just lives his life in a small town south of Dallas, I found myself asking the age-old question when it comes to Stephen King: Is his non-supernatural fiction better than his horror fiction? Yes, he made his name writing all those scary stories in the 1970s and 1980s but some of his most memorable stories involve little or zero supernatural elements: Shawshank Redemption, The Body (Stand by Me), Misery, The Green Mile (yes, there is a supernatural element but the bulk of the story is grounded in reality), and a personal favorite of mine, his non-fiction short story about his son’s Little League season, “Head Down.”
This novel certainly enters this discussion. Because other than the time portal itself, it’s just people with hardly any supernatural elements. Now, I’ll admit that some of the middle section when Jake/George surveils Oswald and his family slows the pace a little, but it didn’t take away from the sheer joy in reading (actually listening to) this book. In fact, I could have listened to another book with Jake/George and the people of Jodie, Texas in the early 1960s and beyond.
I have not read Stephen King in a little while and I’ve had this book on my immediate radar for a few years now. For the past five years or so, as I took down the Halloween decorations on the first of November, I told myself to read 11/22/63. Turns out, this was the year. And I’m really glad I finally read what might ultimately become one of my favorite Stephen King books.
Now…Let’s Talk Spoilers
SPOILER WARNING: Do not read this section unless you’ve read the book.
–
–
–
The Trouble With Changing History and Those Darn Paradoxes
So there are a couple of things that stood out to me regarding the time travel/changing history aspect. And the first one happened when Jake went back in time to save the janitor’s family. And yes, I’ll be using Back to the Future mechanics to discuss this.
Jake changes the future. The janitor, Harry, doesn’t become disabled in 1958 but he ultimately dies in Vietnam. Jake learns this when he calls Harry’s sister in 2011. So, was that a better life, he got to ask himself. Harry, a disabled man who is a janitor, or Harry, the soldier who perished in battle.
Then there’s Al himself. In what I’m calling 2011-A (the timeline we start off in), Al knows and uses the portal, mainly to buy meat at 1958 prices and bringing the meat forward to 2011 and sell it at his diner. But after Jake goes back in time and saves Harry’s family and returns, it’s actually 2011-B. We know this because the photo of Jake and Harry is gone. Al himself doesn’t remember Harry the janitor, but still remembers why Jake went through the portal in the first place. King makes a good case—the “proximity” effect of the portal protects Al—but those mechanics are not 100% accurate. A full creation of 2011-B would have, I think, wiped or changed Al’s memories.
The Back to the Future Part II Section
As a historian, I really loved the idea that history was kind of like a living thing that didn’t want to be changed. Obdurate I think is the word Jake kept using. And I knew the plot mechanics would therefore create hindrances Jake would have to overcome.
But I knew there had to be a moment when Jake returns to 2011 which, according to my discussion here, is 2011-C. This is the world where Kennedy lived…but the world Al imagined is irrevocably changed for the worse.
This was the section I suspect King enjoyed writing: the alternate history of our world. I wanted more, to be honest, but I got the big picture. I love alternate history and never tire of reading it.
I call this the Back to the Future Part 2 section. Just like when Marty McFly returns to 1985, it’s the bad one. Same thing here. Loved this.
The Hardest Choice of All
Jake knows he has to reset the past yet again, in theory returning the world to 2011-A, but I suspect it’s more like 2011-A.1. That’s not the point. The point is that Sadie, the woman with whom he fell in love, would also be reset. And he has to let her go in order to set things right. It’s a hugely emotional element to this book and one that got me somber. There’s another book with this kind of idea—Replay by Ken Grimwood—that resonated with me.
And I really enjoyed the ending. It was wonderful and I definitely felt all the feels. It was only later when I started reading about the story that I learned King’s son, Joe Hill, convinced his dad to scrap his original ending and write the published one.
You see? Even an alternate-history book has an alternate history.
